If you’ve been bitten by the SNAFU that is RegisterFly, there is a new community site that tries to provide help and some answers. At the very least, you can go there and join the pity party.

http://registerflies.com

And by the way, DO NOT, under any circumstances, submit payment to RegisterFly. As I understand it, they are now a rogue operation, accepting payment, but not actually registering/renewing your domains. I urge you to transfer your domains to a new registrar ASAP. GoDaddy is offering a refugee program:

https://www.godaddy.com/gdshop/transfers/registerfly.asp

Maybe ICANN will swoop in on their white horse and save the day, but I wouldn’t count on it.